Monday, 1 September 2014

Was President Richard Nixon a Crook?

In 1973, facing allegations of presidential involvement in the Watergate break in, Richard Nixon proclaimed ‘I am not a crook’. How far was Nixon’s statement true?
“I shall resign the presidency effective at noon tomorrow. Vice President Ford will be sworn in as President at that hour, in this office.” With these words Nixon, the ‘I am not a quitter’ politician, quit. For months prior to his resignation Nixon had been insistent on his desire to make every effort to complete the term of office to which he was elected. However by early August the question was not whether he would resign, but when. An editorial in Times magazine summed up his position: ‘the President will have to give up his office: he has irredeemably lost his moral authority, the confidence of most the country, and therefore his ability to govern effectively’.  In his memoirs Nixon recollects that before the 1972 election he said “that the next four years of (his) administration would become known as having advocated the most significant reforms of any administration since that of Franklin Roosevelt”. However, it was clear just 18 months into his second term that getting any reforms through congress would be a struggle. Congressional support of his party was flailing. This, as Kissinger noted, meant the administration was ‘losing the ability to make credible commitments’. Nixon may have been a fighter but he was also a realist, he knew his limits and conceded that ‘the international situation required a full time President.’ And thus, he resigned in disgrace. Just a month after this resignation the then incumbent President, Gerald Ford, granted Nixon “A full, free and absolute pardon…for all offences against the United States.” All Investigations into Nixon’s conduct as President adjourned. This hereby denied the United States the answer to this most crucial and debated question: was Richard Nixon a crook? In this essay I hope to assess various aspects of the scandal and evaluate whether Nixon’s actions constituted illegal or crooked activity. When accessing the scandal there are, in terms of the legality, three main branches. These are the physical act of burglary, the subsequent obstruction of justice, and whether Nixon purposely lied throughout the period. These will be evaluated throughout to form a conclusion as to whether or not Richard Nixon was in fact “a crook”.
On June 17th “Five men…were arrested…in what authorities described as an elaborate plot to bug the offices of the Democratic National Committee.” This, as first reported by the Washington post was the beginning of Nixon’s fall to the depths of political disgrace, otherwise known as the Watergate scandal. A connection was made between this ‘third rate burglary’ and the President’s own re-election campaign.  Most importantly, members of the Nixon administration and arguably Nixon himself then sought to cover up this connection in order to minimize political damage. This in essence was the scandal which ultimately forced Nixon’s political career to a close. Watergate, from a presidential viewpoint, became much more than a political scandal; it circumscribed the president’s freedom of action and occupied his attention. Nixon’s administration had been pounded by the media since his re-election. Coverage of Watergate, as Nixon himself bitterly described in his memoirs: “had gone on for 20 months without any let up. Day after day it was the lead story in the newspapers. Night after night it led every television news show”. Marvin Kalb has observed that “at one level, Watergate was a battle between a President and a newspaper”. The media, wrongly or rightly had turned on Nixon, and as a result his public and party support had waned substantially. Crucially, on the 27th, 28th and 29th of July 1974, just weeks before his resignation, the House Judiciary Committee approved 3 articles of impeachment- obstruction of justice, abuse of power and contempt of congress. The articles stated that his conduct as president “warrants impeachment and trial, and removal from office.” The main repercussion of this was that should Nixon stay in office he would be put on trial before the house. Even if acquitted the process would take months and leave the country devastated, and as Monica Crawley described would leave ‘a president who was a defendant not a leader’. Nixon understood this; in his memoirs he states ‘the nation could not survive the trauma of a President on trial’. If this wasn’t enough to force Nixon from office, the release of the now infamous ‘smoking gun’ tape certainly was. The tapes were damning. They seemingly showcased the presidents attempt to stop the investigation just 6 days after the break in. Not only does the ‘smoking gun’ tape prove that Nixon knew of the break in before previously claimed, it presents him candidly advising Bob Halderman (Chief of staff) to ‘call the FBI in and say that we wish for the country, don’t go any further into this case’. Within 2 days of the tape becoming public Nixon made the decision to resign, his support in congress had simply evaporated. This, in brief, is the complex series of events known as Watergate which ushered in the President’s resignation.
Firstly, at the heart of the scandal was of course the burglary. The Code of Virginia, the state in which Watergate occurred, define Burglary as “Entering dwelling, house, etc., with intent to commit larceny, assault and battery or other felony. If any person commits any of the acts mentioned…he shall be guilty of statutory burglary.” By this the 5 Watergate burglars, Bernard Barker, Virgilio Gonzalez, Eugenio Martinez, James W. McCord, Jr., and Frank Sturgis, were guilty of statutory burglary. However, as Sigmund Freud argued, “It is a matter of indifference who actually committed the crime; psychology is only concerned to know who desired it emotionally and who welcomed it when it was done”. Not only was this all psychology is concerned to know, it is also what the special prosecution investigating Watergate sought to find out. Once links to the Nixon administration had been established it became paramount to address the Presidents involvement. In Richard Nixon’s memoirs he described the notion that he ordered the break-in as the ‘most blatantly false myth’. He argued that “millions of dollars were spent by the executive branch, the congress, and the office of the special prosecutor to investigate Watergate. Not one piece of evidence was discovered indicating that I ordered the break-in, knew about the plans for the wiretapping, or received any information from it.” However, in his memoirs Nixon also admitted that he saw nothing wrong with such burglaries. Nixon also made this apparent during the Frost Nixon interviews in which he stated, “When the president does it, that means it is not illegal.” This represents the “strongly held view within certain precincts of the White House that the president and those functioning on his behalf could carry out illegal acts with impunity if they were convinced that the nation’s security demanded it.” In legal terms, these claims towards executive power held no bearing and were simply a way for Nixon and those around him to justify the morally questionable acts they committed. This offers a worrying insight into how far Nixon thought his executive power stretched and also alludes that he did have the moral capacity to order such activity.
      Some evidence has surfaced since Nixon’s death suggesting he may have ordered the break in at the democratic headquarters at the Watergate complex. Jeb Magruder, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy and perjury charges stemming from the break-in and spent seven months in prison, broke his three decades of silence on Nixon's culpability in 2003. His revised story of affairs was that Nixon knew everything from the beginning. Magruder says that on March 30, 1972, “he met with Mitchell and discussed a plan by G. Gordon Liddy, a former FBI agent, to break into the Democratic Party headquarters to bug O'Brien's phone.” Later this day Magruder claims that he overheard the President tell John Mitchell that “we need to get the information on Larry O'Brien, and the only way we can do that is through Liddy's plan. And you need to do that." However historians, such as Stanley Kutcher, have since called these claims "the dubious word of a dubious character." We are therefore left with circumstantial evidence relating to the Presidents direct involvement and strong assumptions that the President must have known of the covert operation. Therefore, with regards to the physical act of burglary, claims of Nixon being ‘a crook’ cannot be upheld.  
Whilst Watergate represents the most famous crime committed under the Nixon administration, it does not represent the only “White house horror”. The group that carried out the Watergate burglaries were known as ‘The Plumbers’. They were formed as a response to the Pentagon Papers, classified information chronicling the USA’s involvement in Vietnam (1945-1967), being leaked by Daniel Ellsberg. The papers proved that “the Johnson Administration had systematically lied, not only to the public but also to Congress” and this proved detrimental to executive power. President Nixon viewed the leak as a matter of critical importance to national security. As a result he established the group, later coined  ‘the Plumbers’, to find out how the leak had happened and to stem further leaks from happening, in this endeavour its members branched into illegal activities. The first “covert operation” was initiated “to get a “mother lode” of information about Mr. Ellsberg’s mental state, to discredit him, by breaking into the office of his psychiatrist, Dr. Lewis Fielding”. This operation was urged by and completed under the stewardship of leading members G. Gordon Liddy and E. Howard Hunt. This was also approved by John Ehrlichman “if done under the assurance that it is not traceable.” On September 3, 1971, the burglary of Lewis Fielding's office was carried out by Hunt, Liddy and CIA officers Eugenio Martínez, Felipe de Diego and Bernard Barker. The "Plumbers" failed to find Ellsberg's file. Egil Krogh, the man who officially approved the break in, later pleaded guilty to criminal conspiracy in depriving Dr. Fielding of his civil rights, specifically his constitutional right to be free from an unwarranted search. He later stated that “I no longer believed that national security could justify my conduct.” What this proves is that the Watergate break-in was in no way an isolated incident, but rather an extension of criminal activity which perpetuated throughout Nixon’s tenure. Nixon had created a situation in which the men he surrounded himself with were willing to undertake criminal activity for the administrations gain, the fault of this lies at the crooked nature of the regime Nixon created. Ultimately Nixon had instigated the inception of ‘the plumbers’ and provided the means for illegal activity to be carried out, this goes some way to substantiating claims that Nixon was ‘a crook’.
One argument often cited by key Nixon aides which suggests Nixon either ordered the break-in or was later involved is that Nixon was definitively the ‘man on top’. Alexander Butterfield, Halderman’s aide, set the President’s daily schedule and as such was in close contact with Nixon each day. During his testament to the house judiciary committee Butterfield chronicled Nixon’s daily operations in sublime detail. One area he describes is Nixon’s preoccupation with detail. Nixon, according to Butterfield and validated by the Presidents memoranda’s, was concerned about what curtains were open or closed, on which side of the room gifts should be placed for visiting dignitaries, and  the table arrangements for social dinners.Butterfield remarked that these were ‘typical of a thoughtful, careful and well disciplined man … highly interested in detail’. This detail to administration is also showcased in his delegation of authority. He would often appoint two men to the same task and work them in different ways. Importantly, each man was unaware of the tasks their colleagues had been assigned. This is known as compartmentalization and ensured the fragmentation of power. All this was in order for Nixon to keep firm control. Harry Dent, another Nixon aide, corroborates with Butterfield in stating that ‘nothing happened around that White House willy-nilly, the man on top was on top”.Here Nixon is painted as a man who strived for meticulous detail and control within his administration. From this depiction we can infer that it is implausible that Nixon could have obliviously allowed an event such as Watergate to occur. For a man who placed such importance on trivial aspects of his administration it seems unlikely he would simply be unaware of the number of illegal activities that were occurring.
     It is equally unlikely that Nixon’s aides would have acted without the President’s approval or knowledge. The role that aides such as Halderman and Ehrlichman played in the administration was as functionaries, carrying out the role and duties designed by President Nixon. All evidence characterises these aides as extensions of Nixon, ‘not men of ideas’. Harry Dent, another Nixon aide, has since scoffed at the notion that Nixon could not control his subordinates: “I know from whence every order came…you couldn’t be around without knowing that everything came from one well, one spring”. The spring in question was of course Nixon. To believe the President had been unaware of the crimes being committed around him by the men he saw on a daily basis seems a leap into the realm of fiction. Nixon ultimately had the message, and in men such as Halderman he had his medium. Therefore, whilst other men may have been instrumental in the Watergate affair it seems probable that Nixon himself was similarly entrenched in the cover-up. Should this be true Nixon can be deemed ‘a crook’.
“If a cover up is for the purpose of covering up criminal activities it is illegal, if however, a cover up as you (David Frost) have called it, is for a motive that is not criminal, that is something else again, and my motive was not criminal. I did not believe we were covering up any criminal activity… My motive was pure political containment, and political containment in not a corrupt motive…my motive was not criminal.” This was the defence Nixon utilised in absolving himself from claims that he had obstructed justice. These claims derived from the aforementioned smoking gun tape in which Nixon told Halderman to ‘call the FBI in and say that we wish for the country, don’t go any further into this case’. At this point, on June 23rd, only 5 men involved had been arrested and Nixon arguably knew of the involvement of Howard Hunt and Gordon Liddy. So, as David Frost rebutted, Nixon knew in terms of intent and in terms of foreseeable consequence that the result of the cover-up would be that Hunt and Liddy, who were criminally liable, would be protected. This by definition would be obstruction of justice.
     However, all of is irrelevant if we do not access Nixon’s motives. As Nixon was keen to emphasise for this cover-up to be a criminal act, the person who incited the cover-up must have had a corrupt intent or motive. Retrospectively it is easy to perceive Nixon’s motive as a clear attempt to steer authorities from investigating his administration and its inherent corruption. Nixon on the other hand maintained that his motive was pure political containment. He later fully justified these claims in his autobiography stating that, given the links between the CIA and Watergate, investigation by the FBI had the potential to reveal other legitimate operations and operatives which could be damaging to the CIA and so he thought they would welcome the chance to avoid such an outcome.
      Nixon offers further defence in the fact that the FBI never actually complied with his plea to stop the investigation. He recollects a phone call between himself and FBI director Pat Grey, in which Nixon told him empathetically to go ahead with the investigation and Nixon subsequently, instructed his staff to cooperate with the investigation throughout. However, had Nixon not been confronted by the FBI the attempts to stop the investigation would have continued. It is therefore not a defence that Nixon had failed in his efforts to obstruct justice. Nixon, had still conspired to obstruct justice and a period remains between June 23rd and July 12th (when the Phone call took place) when justice was potentially, obstructed.
     Overall I see this as Nixon’s attempt to appease his conscious through use of strict legal rhetoric. Taking the law as gospel, an argument could be put forward that Nixon was oblivious to the overarching links to his administration and was purely covering up to avoid political embarrassment. The potential obstruction of justice that could have resulted from this was unintentional and unavoidable. Under law, if proved, this absolves Nixon from this aspect of the Watergate crimes. However, the fact was that he did, for whatever reasons, cover up the affair. Had he been successful criminals such as Hunt, Liddy and John Mitchell would have escaped Justice. Whether Nixon knew this was the case or not it was always a possibility, and as such, the cover-up in my view highlights Nixon’s moral crookedness.
Unbeknown to the President the cover up continued. Nixon was allegedly not told the true extent of the Cover up until March 21th 1973 when John Dean told him that “I think that there is no doubt about the seriousness of the problem we’ve got. We have a cancer within, close to the presidency that is growing.” The cancer being referenced was the snowballing cover up scandal that now conspired to obstruct justice through the use of hush money and executive clemency. On March 21st John Dean laid out many of the key elements of this cover up to the President. He listed the criminal liability of himself and other top Nixon aides such as Halderman, Ehrlichman, and told the president that hundreds of thousands of dollars had been paid to keep the Watergate burglars silent though their January trial. He also spoke of how this cover up was still ongoing with Howard Hunt, one of the engineers of the Watergate burglary, now demanded $120,000 for continued silence. Dean later testified that the primary objective of this meeting was to explain that to perpetuate the cover-up successfully, continued perjury and continued support of these individuals would be required. To avoid this Dean argued that all those involved should stand up and account for themselves and the President himself must get out in front. Nixon refused to countenance Dean’s advice and the result was that he arguably rejoined the conspiracy. Dean concluded that, “It was quite clear that the cover-up as far as the White House was concerned was going to continue.” This was also confirmed in notes made by Halderman which stated that the President keeps working “every day on trying to develop ways of finding some statement that we can put out that shows that we’re not just covering it up.” Nixon was now knowingly protecting the members of his administration who had contributed to the Hush money cover-up, a clear example of Nixon illegally obstructing justice.
        The idea of Nixon obstructing justice is evidenced by the fact that Hunt did receive a further $75,000 as a direct result of this March conversation. The transcript of this conversation reveals that Nixon, on his own initiative, “discussed accommodating blackmail demands on at least a half-dozen occasions during the meeting without once suggesting that paying the men for their silence would be wrong”. Rather than stop the events Nixon arguably condoned them. In the meeting Nixon recognised that the purpose of these payments would be "to keep the cap on the bottle," to "buy time," to "tough it through" and he even stated that “You (Halderman) could get a million dollars. You could get it in cash. I know where it could be gotten. I mean it’s not easy but it could be done.” Notably, during all these exchanges, at no point does the President suggest that the payment of hush money would be legally and morally wrong. Nixon later admitted that whilst he had toyed with the idea of paying the defendants he was aware the ultimate end to this mean would be granting clemency, and “you can’t provide clemency.” Nixon also argued that the payment made to Hunt occurred parallel to this meeting rather than as a result of a presidential order. Whilst this was true to some extent, the final order on what to do about the money did come from the President in the meeting. This is evidenced by the transcripts which show that “the final frantic order issued by Nixon to Dean and H.R. Halderman on the need to pay Hunt was “For Christ’s sakes get the money!”. Therefore, even if Hunt would have been granted the Hush money regardless of Nixon’s orders, the fact Nixon would have ordered Hush money to be given further proves that he was ‘a crook’. These claims are further invalidated by the fact that the president failed to act once informed of the payment to Hunt. The result of this failure was that Howard Hunt, upon receiving the money, subsequently lied to the Watergate Grand Jury, denying knowledge of any involvement of higher-ranking White House or Nixon campaign officials in the conspiracy. This was not the only repercussion of these March discussions. Historian Stanley Kutler describes the March 21st discussions as an overture to the series of meetings that began the next day and continued into April. During these discussions emphasis was placed on manoeuvring John Mitchell into position to take responsibility for Watergate, leaving the President and his entourage relatively immune. The result of this exploit, if successful, was that men such as Dean, Halderman and Ehrlichman, who had been open about their own criminal liability, would escape justice.  The ‘corrupt motive’ Nixon cites as being the defining aspect of a cover-up is found here. The motive of ‘pure political containment’ was no longer relevant –the motive displayed here is criminal containment, this was a corrupt motive. Nixon’s own definition of an illegal cover up was that “If a cover up is for the purpose of covering up criminal activities it is illegal.” Therefore, the final result of the March conversation was that the president was made aware of the perpetuating cover-up scandal; the decision of Nixon not to act upon this knowledge constitutes an illegal cover-up.
      Also whether Nixon had advance knowledge of this cover-up has gone unanswered since Senator Howard Baker first asked, at hearings of the Senate Watergate Committee, "What did the president know, and when did he know it?”. Had Nixon known of the cover-up prior to March 1973 then he arguably must have contributed to its initial orchestration. The responsibility of organising the initial cover-up fell to Nixon’s personal lawyer, Herbert Kalmbach, who distributed $187,000 in “hush money” to the burglars between June and September 1973.  After this, the distribution was handled by former Mitchell aide Frederick LaRue, who would hand out a further $230,000. When questioned about his knowledge of these pay offs Nixon maintained that he “did not learn of it until the March period”. However, James Reston, Jr later wrote that Kalmbach’s involvement is “strong circumstantial” evidence “that Nixon must have known about the process from the beginning. Had the president’s lawyer been caught at this task, it would have associated the President with the break-in in the summer of 1972, and no one but Nixon would logically have authorized such a risky procedure.” It seems unlikely that a President, who has been described as the ‘man on top’, could be oblivious to the unfolding and ballooning Watergate scandal for an 11 month period. This was compounded by a set of comments made by the President on the 13th and 14th February, 1973. Nixon stated that “This tremendous investigation rests, unless one of the seven begins to talk, that’s the problem” and just a day later demanded (to Colson) that “the President’s loss has got to be cut on the cover-up deal”. These comments offer a profound understanding of a cover-up the President allegedly was not yet aware of.
      However, it is ultimately a trivial detail as to when Nixon learnt of the cover-up because once officially told of the revelations Nixon failed to act. In doing so Nixon allowed himself and members within his administration to commit perjury and ultimately obstruct justice. The Dean meeting occurred simultaneously with a letter from James W. McCord being received by Judge John Sirica (the man presiding over the Watergate trials). McCord claimed that the Watergate defendants had pleaded guilty under duress as “there was political pressure applied to the defendants to plead guilty and remain silent” resulting in “Perjury occurring during the trial”. The political pressure referenced was the urging of John Dean, Counsel to the President, and John Mitchell, the Attorney-General. These allegations of a “cover-up and obstruction of justice by the highest law officers in the land blew Watergate wide open.” This truly contextualises the inherent madness and lack of foresight shown in Nixon’s decision to try and stop the Watergate earthquake from occurring. Despite the truth regarding Watergate slowly being disclosed to the public, on March 28, acting on Nixon's orders, aide John Ehrlichman told attorney general Richard Kleindienst that nobody in the White House had prior knowledge of the burglary. In doing so Nixon allowed the cover-up of his administrations involvement to continue, this was obstruction of justice and goes some way to proving Nixon may have been crooked.  
Following the March 21st conversations the Watergate scandal slowly unravelled in the public domain. The biggest development in the affair came when Alexander Butterfield confirmed the existence of the White House taping system in an interview conducted by Senate Committee. The significance of this was any claims made by the white house could be substantiated by the white house tapes which “were to act as gospel”. As a response to this new potential evidence Special Counsel Archibald Cox, asked District Court Judge John Sirica to subpoena eight relevant tapes to confirm the testimony of White House Counsel John Dean. Nixon refused to relinquish the tapes in a drama that would last several months and further question Nixon’s moral crookedness.
       Nixon’s refusal to abide by this first subpoena cumulated in the Saturday Night Massacre. Nixon ordered the incumbent Attorney General, Elliot Richardson, to dismiss Archibald Cox. He refused and resigned. Deputy Attorney General, William Ruckelshaus, was given the same order and also refused, resulting in his resignation. That left Robert Bork, the Solicitor General, as Acting Attorney General. He dismissed “Mr. Cox on the President's orders, a move that ignited a storm of criticism from Congress and set the stage for impeachment proceedings against Mr. Nixon.” The act was seen as a gross abuse of presidential power and congress later ruled that the dismissal of Cox was illegal. As Nixon was the instigator of this illegal dismissal he was criminally liable, and thus could be deemed a crook.
       Following Cox’s dismissal Leon Jaworski was appointed as the new special prosecutor.  He, much like his predecessor, was concerned with the potential content of the White house tapes and so in April 1974, Jaworski obtained a subpoena ordering certain tapes between Nixon and those indicted by the grand jury to be released. Nixon once again refused citing executive privileges. In a legal battle, coined “United States VS Nixon”, Nixon’s attorney argued this executive privilege stating that: “he (the President) is as powerful a monarch as Louis XIV, only four years at a time, and is not subject to the processes of any court in the land except the court of impeachment.” This motion was declined and Nixon was forced to hand over the tapes by May 31st 1974. The content of the tapes, as described by Nixon, was “Dozens of hours of frank and earthly conversations that I clearly would have preferred not to see made public.” The reason Nixon did not want the tapes released was they were ultimately incriminating. This proves that Nixon was attempting to obstruct justice by withholding evidence which proved he was criminally liable. Also this attempt to cling on to power shows Nixon’s moral crookedness. By this time Nixon knew he had committed various offences that warranted his impeachment. His response, as opposed to resigning, was to continue to drag the Presidency into disrepute. He left his resignation too late, mere days after he had been caught out. Nixon was aware he would ultimately be forced out of office, by continuing his presidency Nixon chose himself over his country – highlighting his moral crookedness.
Ultimately, Nixon was at the helm of an administration in which over 40 officials were indicted on crimes relating to Watergate and its ensuing perjury, most notably the Watergate seven. The Watergate seven refers to the seven advisors and aides to Nixon who were indicted by a grand jury on March 1, 1974 for their role in the Watergate scandal. This included John Mitchell, former United States Attorney General, who was found guilty of obstruction of justice, conspiracy and perjury and sentenced to two and a half to eight years in prison. Also, Bob Haldeman, the “second most powerful man in Nixon’s administration’, and John Ehrlichman, Nixon’s chief domestic adviser, were both convicted of conspiracy and obstruction of justice and received 18-month prison sentences. In contrast, Nixon was acquitted by President Ford in October 1974, denying a full legal investigation into Nixon’s conduct. However, if we were to surmise, it is clear Nixon like much of his administration would have been deemed criminally liable. Nixon was the President, the so called ‘man on top’, and so legal liability falls to him even before the evidence of his own illegality is taken into account. Therefore, when the evidence showing Nixon candidly initiating the cover-up and later supporting the payment of hush money is addressed it becomes blatantly clear Nixon was guilty. The bottom line is that if Mitchell, Haldeman and Ehrlichman were all guilty of conspiracy and obstruction of justice, so was the President.
As previously mentioned, we can break the scandal, in terms of legality, into three branches: the physical act of burglary, the subsequent obstruction of justice, and whether Nixon purposely lied throughout the period. The physical act of burglary cannot be attributed to Nixon, we can only assume he may have known or authorised the break-in, but this remains unproven. However what can be proven is the president’s role in the obstruction of justice. The President consistently withheld knowledge of, and even initiated illegal, covert activity as evidenced throughout this essay. The so coined smoking gun tape proves that just days after the Watergate break-in the president was willing to cover up the affair, thus protecting those criminally liable. Whilst this first attempt to cover-up the affair ultimately failed it proves Nixon’s willingness to break the law and be ‘a crook’. This is further evidenced by the fact Nixon, following the March 21st meeting with John Dean, allowed the silencing of Watergate defendants through the use of ‘hush money’ to continue. In doing so Nixon rejoined the conspiracy to obstruct justice. Finally, allowing the cover-up to continue facilitated the Presidents lies throughout the Watergate period. The President would later describe the fact that he “deliberately lied’ as a “myth”, citing “error of recollection not a deliberate falsehood”. However, one area Nixon describes as an error of recollection is the June 23rd conversation with Halderman in which he ordered the investigation to be stopped. Given the furore surrounding Watergate it seems unlikely that such a key conversation could simply be misremembered. Ultimately, all factors considered, we must conclude that Richard Nixon, in terms of legal liability, is in no way innocent. This is the same conclusion reached by the special prosecutors following Richard Nixon’s resignation. In a memorandum, issued on August 9th, the prosecutors concluded that “there is clear evidence that Richard M. Nixon participated in a conspiracy to obstruct justice by concealing the identity of those responsible for the Watergate break-in and other criminal offences.”  As a result, Richard Nixon, for crimes committed in the Watergate scandal, was a crook.


Bibliography
Books
  • Woodward, B. & Bernstein, C. (1974). All the President’s men. Simon & Schuster
  • Woodward, B. & Bernstein, C. (1976). The Final Days. Simon & Schuster
  • Dallek, R. (2007). Nixon and Kissinger partners in power. Penguin books
  • Kutchler, S (1990). The Wars of Watergate. Norton
  • Nixon, R. (1978). RN: The memoirs of Richard Nixon. Simon & Schuster
  • Nixon, R. (1990). In the Arena: A Memoir of Victory, Defeat, and Renewal. Simon & Schuster
  • Frost, D (2008). Frost/Nixon. Macmillan
  • N/A. (1974). The White house transcripts. The New York Times
  • Frost, D. (1978). ‘I gave them a sword’ Frost on Nixon. Macmillan
  • terHorst, J. (1974). Gerald Ford. W.H. Allen
  • Sussman, Barry. The Great Coverup: Nixon and the Scandal of Watergate. New York, NY: New American Library, 1974.
  • Kissinger, H, (2011). Years of Upheaval: The Second Volume of His Classic Memoir, USA, Simon and Schuster
  • Kalb, (1994). The Nixon Memo: Political Respectability, Russia, and the Press, USA, University Of Chicago Press
  • Dean, John. Blind Ambition: The White House Years. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1976.
  • Ehrlichman, John. Witness to Power: the Nixon Years. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1982.
  • Grabaurd, Stephen R. Kissinger: Portrait of a Mind. New York: Norton, 1973.
  • Hanhimaki, Jussi. The Flawed Architect. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
  • Hersh, Seymour. The Price of Power: Kissinger in the White House. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1983.
  • Nixon, Richard M. The Presidential Transcripts. New York: Delacorte Press, 1974.
  • Bramwell, Dana Glenn. The Tragedy of King Richard: Shakespearean Watergate. Salina, KS: Survey Publishers, 1974.
  • Archer, Jules. Watergate: America in Crisis. New York, NY: Crowell, 1975.
  • Axel-Lute, Paul. Checklist of Federal Documents on Watergate, Impeachment & Presidential Transition, 1973-1974. Newark, NJ: P. Axel-Lute, 1975.
  • Ball, Howard. "We Have a Duty": The Supreme Court and the Watergate Tapes Litigation. New York, NY: Greenwood Press, 1990.
Primary sources


Journals
  • Morgan, R. (1996). “Nixon, Watergate, and the study of the presidency,” Vol. 26, the Nixon presidency: 217-238
  • Stathis, S. (1983). “Nixon, Watergate, and American foreign policy,” Vol.13, the economy in presidential policy: 217-238


Newspaper or magazine
  • Grunwald, H. (1973, November 12th). ‘The President should resign’. Time magazine, Vol 102,No. 20
  • Lewis, A, E, (1972). ‘5 Held in Plot to Bug Democrats' Office Here’. The Washington Post, June 18, Pg, 1


WebPages
  • N/A (2003). Magruder: Nixon personally gave order for Watergate break-in. Available: http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/washington/2003-07-27-watergate_x.htm. Last accessed 17th Oct 2013.
  • Egil Krough (2007). The Break-In That History Forgot. Available: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/06/30/opinion/30krogh.html?_r=1&. Last accessed 20th Aug 2013.
  • R.W. APPLE. (1996). Lessons From the Pentagon Papers. Available: http://www.nytimes.com/books/97/04/13/reviews/papers-lessons.html. Last accessed 20th Nov 2013.
Videos
  • “The Nixon interviews” Nixon, RM (1977). Interview with David Frost. March 23rd. California.
  • The Real Richard Nixon
Radio
  • Cooke, A. 1974. Letter from America: Nixon's resignation. LFA. [podcast] Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/series/lfanixoncarter/all [Accessed: 5 Sept 2013].
  • Cooke, A. 1974. Letter from America: Should Nixon Resign? LFA. [podcast] Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/series/lfanixoncarter/all [Accessed: 5 Sept 2013].
  • Cooke, A. 1974. Letter from America: Watergate hearings. LFA. [podcast] Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/series/lfanixoncarter/all [Accessed: 5 Sept 2013].

No comments:

Post a Comment